The judge who presided around Invoice Cosby’s criminal situation claimed he enable 5 other accusers testify at the intercourse-assault trial since their accounts experienced “chilling similarities” that pointed to a “signature” crime.
A jury very last 12 months convicted Cosby of drugging and sexually assaulting Andrea Constand in 2004, immediately after listening to from her and the five some others. Cosby, 81, is attractive his conviction based on the women’s testimony and other crucial rulings by Montgomery County Choose Stephen O’Neill.
Cosby commenced serving a 3- to 10-calendar year jail term in September at a point out jail around Philadelphia.
O’Neill, in a prolonged impression filed Tuesday, claimed he identified “striking similarities” in the women’s descriptions of their encounters with the comic extended beloved as “America’s Dad.”
“In each and every occasion, (he) satisfied a considerably more youthful girl, obtained her belief, invited her to a spot where by he was by yourself with her, furnished her with a consume or drug, and sexually assaulted her when she was rendered incapacitated,” O’Neill wrote. “These chilling similarities rendered (their) testimony admissible.”
Cosby and his wife Camille Cosby wrote in a statement to HuffPost that racism was the principal reasoning at the rear of O’Neill’s feeling.
“Now, soon after far more than 50 yrs of do the job, that humanized the dehumanized which also challenged the perpetual architects of racist, exploitive and greedy maneuvers that have enabled them to divide and conquer,” Camille Cosby wrote. “My husband has been severely redefined by Decide O’Neill, regardless of acquiring zero proof.”
“Judge O’Neill, with a wonderful deal of support from the media, has tried using to switch Monthly bill Cosby into a person of the most insidious stereotypes of African American men… the brutal, black buck,” she additional.
Cosby wrote that he stands with his spouse “on the foundation of solidarity and real truth,” including: “Camille has often been a fearless warrior versus corruption and bigotry. She’s not fearful of this unethical choose, nor am I worried of O’Neill’s grossly immoral methods.”
O’Neill experienced authorized just a single other accuser to testify at Cosby’s to start with demo in June 2017, when a jury deadlock led to a mistrial. Cosby was retried in April 2018, months after the #MeToo movement burst into view with sexual assault accusations towards producer Harvey Weinstein and other potent gentlemen in Hollywood and outside of.
In the ruling Tuesday, O’Neill said the new defense crew that managed Cosby’s retrial by no means specifically challenged him on the change in his two trial rulings about the other accusers’ testimony. At any fee, he reported, judges are not bound by their prior choices.
The protection, in outlining their enchantment difficulties, have also argued that Cosby had a binding arrangement with a previous prosecutor, Bruce Castor, that he would never ever be charged in the situation. O’Neill all over again rejected the declare Tuesday, getting the signed push release from Castor ― utilized to bolster the claim ― falls quick of an immunity agreement.
Castor had investigated Constand’s complaint for about a month in 2005 in advance of selecting not to convey a scenario, questioning why she waited a calendar year to get hold of police. Prior to the yr was out, 13 other accusers experienced occur ahead to guidance the lawsuit Constand submitted in opposition to Cosby. He settled the case for $3.4 million.
When Cosby’s deposition testimony from the lawsuit turned public in 2015, and the criminal case was reopened, Castor for the first time explained to his successor about the meant “non-prosecution” agreement. He forwarded their correspondence to Cosby’s defense attorney and testified as a defense witness at a 2016 hearing, O’Neill observed.
O’Neill also turned down defense efforts to have him phase down from the case since of his alleged bias, and outlined the 4-calendar year lawful approach that led up to Cosby’s conviction and sentencing.
Cosby’s most up-to-date staff of attorneys has been awaiting the belief so they can commence with the attraction in Pennsylvania courts. The lead lawyer, Brian Perry, did not immediately return a phone message on Tuesday.
Cosby spokesman Andrew Wyatt, in a assertion, stated “O’Neill has a recurring practice of generally attempting to address his lots of errors, which continues to present his hatred toward Mr. Cosby.”
The Involved Press does not normally determine sexual assault victims without having their authorization, which Constand has granted.
HuffPost contributed to this posting.
Real Life. Authentic Information. True VOICES.
Assist us tell additional of the stories that make a difference from voices that far too frequently remain unheard.